TL;DR:
- An AI-generated voice on YouTube channels threatens jobs in the dubbing industry.
- Professionals fear that AI will replace human workers in the industry.
- While the speed of AI technology is unmatched, its sound quality is still subpar compared to human voices.
- The emergence of AI in the industry remains a concern for many creative professionals.
- The impact of AI on human jobs remains uncertain.
- AI has a double edge, as it can be extremely useful but also cause problems.
- The risk of job loss is more significant now, as AI can replace not only physical jobs but also intellectual tasks.
- Companies using free AI technology could take over every broadcasting job without paying human workers.
- It is essential to find ways to balance the benefits and risks of AI to avoid the loss of jobs and protect human workers.
Main AI News:
Artificial Intelligence Sends Shockwaves through Dubbing Industry
The emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) in the dubbing industry has sent shockwaves through the job market, causing fear among professionals who fear for their careers. Alejandro Graue, a voice-over and dubbing actor from Argentina, is one of them. Graue had been working on a project for a YouTube channel since November and had turned down other job offers as this project required a lot of effort. However, after returning from a holiday break, he discovered that the channel had uploaded a new video in Spanish, and the voice was generated by AI.
“It was an automated voice, and it had no richness, no nuance, no rhythm. The pronunciation was totally mechanical,” said Graue. “Hearing that artificial voice on the video had a huge impact on me. I fear for my future. Dubbing has been my job for the last 18 years, and I have two small daughters now.”
Graue’s situation is not an isolated case, and many professionals in the dubbing industry are concerned that AI will replace them. The big question is whether companies that aim to cut costs can replace human workers with artificial intelligence without losing something else in the process.
Despite the poor sound quality of the AI-generated voice on the YouTube channel, Graue acknowledges that the technology’s speed is unmatched. “What is indisputable is that we will never be able to compete with it in terms of time. You give this technology a script, and within five minutes, you have it processed and voiced. The only thing left is to do a final check.“
The YouTube channel that had uploaded videos with AI-generated voice received complaints from users within weeks, leading the channel to delete the last videos made with the artificial voice. While this may offer some comfort to professionals like Graue, the increasing use of AI in the industry is still a cause for concern for many.
The Double-Edged Sword of Artificial Intelligence on Human Jobs
The impact of artificial intelligence on human jobs is still uncertain, and experts are questioning whether the widespread replacement of jobs will indeed occur. Guillermo Simari, a professor of Artificial Intelligence and Computational Logic at the Universidad Nacional del Sur de Bahía Blanca in Argentina, recognizes that AI has both advantages and disadvantages, as it can be incredibly beneficial but can also create problems.
Simari believes that AI technology is not expected to replace all jobs in the foreseeable future. He cites the invention of the car as an example, where many people lost their jobs, but they eventually found complementary ones. However, the problem today is that the risk of job loss is more significant, as AI can replace not only physical jobs but also intellectual tasks that were once exclusive to the human brain.
For the first time in history, creative professionals en masse are threatened, and they can see their work done by machines. The use of synthetic voices and the absence of copyright could lead to the loss of thousands of jobs, including those of voice-over artists and illustrators. Alejandro Graue, the Argentinian actor, warns that if companies are free to use this technology, they can take over every broadcasting job without paying people.
As AI continues to advance, it is essential to find ways to balance its benefits and risks to avoid the loss of jobs and protect human workers. The debate on the impact of AI on the workforce is ongoing, and experts must find ways to minimize the negative effects while maximizing the technology’s positive contributions.
Conlcusion:
The emergence of artificial intelligence in the dubbing industry has raised concerns among professionals who fear for their careers. While AI has an unmatched speed of processing and voicing scripts, its sound quality is still subpar compared to human voices.
However, the risk of job loss is significant, as AI can replace not only physical jobs but also intellectual tasks exclusive to the human brain. As AI continues to advance, it is essential to find ways to balance its benefits and risks to avoid the loss of jobs and protect human workers.
