TL;DR:
- Toronto is emerging as a strong AI cluster, drawing attention away from Silicon Valley.
- The city’s growth in the tech sector is driven by factors like the University of Toronto’s contributions and a thriving startup scene.
- Prominent companies like Samsung, Google, and Nvidia have established AI research centers in Toronto.
- U of T’s interdisciplinary approach to AI education and its collaboration with UNICEF contributes to the city’s AI ecosystem.
- Challenges include competing with Silicon Valley’s VC ecosystem and the need for AI regulation in Canada.
- Despite these challenges, Toronto’s AI growth is fueled by increased investment and a commitment to innovation.
Main AI News:
In recent years, Toronto has solidified its status as a burgeoning artificial intelligence (AI) epicenter, giving Silicon Valley a run for its money. This emerging AI cluster is home to a multitude of companies, organizations, and institutions fervently dedicated to advancing the AI field, with their collective successes fueling the region’s rapid growth.
While Silicon Valley has long held the limelight as the tech mecca, the AI revolution has positioned Toronto as an increasingly appealing hub for AI-focused startups. Much of this allure can be attributed to the pioneering work of Geoffrey Hinton, Professor Emeritus in the Department of Computer Science at the University of Toronto, who has earned the industry moniker of the ‘godfather of AI.’
In a recent 2023 tech talent ranking by Coldwell Banker Richard Ellis (CBRE), Toronto secured the fifth spot, following Bay Area, Seattle, New York Metro, and Washington, DC. The ranking, based on 13 key metrics, assesses the depth and vitality of each market in terms of its attractiveness to tech companies and professionals seeking employment.
CBRE’s report also highlights Toronto’s remarkable growth in the tech sector, trailing closely behind the Bay Area in job expansion. It boasts the third-largest tech workforce and is the second-fastest-growing destination for North American tech talent, having added a staggering 63,800 jobs between 2017 and 2022.
Jordan Jacobs, Managing Partner and Co-Founder of Radical Ventures, an AI-focused venture fund born in Toronto, points out a significant transformation in the city’s startup landscape over the past decade. He notes that a decade ago, people were eager to leave Toronto, but today, it has become a magnet for innovative companies such as Samsung, Google, Nvidia, LG Electronics, Roche, and Johnson & Johnson, all of which have established AI research and development laboratories in the city.
The University of Toronto (U of T) has played a pivotal role in driving AI growth in Toronto. The 2022 Academic Ranking of World Universities ranked U of T 15th globally for computer science and engineering. Previously, many graduates from the university migrated to Silicon Valley, but now, they are increasingly contributing to Toronto’s burgeoning AI startup scene.
For instance, U of T startups Waabi and Cohere have garnered recognition on the 2023 Forbes 50 AI list, celebrating privately-owned North American companies that make the most innovative use of artificial technology. Waabi focuses on self-driving technology for long-haul trucking, while Cohere specializes in generative AI, aiding companies in integrating natural language processing.
Jai Mansukhani and Alexis Tassone, co-presidents of UofT AI, a club at the University of Toronto, have noticed a significant uptick in AI-related opportunities for undergraduate students. They credit the Toronto-based Vector Institute, an independent nonprofit dedicated to AI research, as a catalyst for students’ research and internship opportunities, setting them on the path to post-graduation employment in Toronto.
Professor Avi Goldfarb, the Rotman Chair in Artificial Intelligence and Healthcare, underscores U of T’s contributions to AI development. He highlights that many of the core technologies underpinning recent AI advancements originated here, emphasizing the university’s role as a driving force behind Toronto’s AI ecosystem.
Hayoung (Gloria) Son, a third-year UTSG student, points out that U of T’s strength lies in its interdisciplinary approach to AI education, extending beyond the computer science department. She emphasizes the importance of studying AI from diverse perspectives, such as law, ethics, and public policy, and highlights U of T’s collaboration with UNICEF in utilizing AI for non-profit humanitarian goals.
U of T is also in the process of constructing the Schwartz Reisman Innovation Centre, which will house the Schwartz Reisman Institute for Technology and Society. This research center will focus on exploring the societal implications of emerging technologies, including AI.
Challenges on the Horizon
Despite Toronto’s meteoric rise in the AI world, it faces a crucial question: can it rival Silicon Valley’s well-established venture capital (VC) ecosystem? VC funding is the lifeblood of startups, enabling them to turn their visions into reality.
In 2014, Atomwise, a Toronto-based startup, was among the pioneers in applying AI to drug discovery but eventually relocated to Silicon Valley for better access to capital. However, recent successes like Deep Genomics in Toronto and Shopify in Ottawa choosing to remain in Canada demonstrate that the VC ecosystem is improving. As of 2023, a Deloitte report ranked Canada third in per capita VC investment in AI among the G7 countries, with the US leading the pack, followed by the UK.
Jai Mansukhani, founder of his own AI startup, Ace It, highlights a significant difference in risk appetite between US and Canadian investors. Investors in San Francisco are often more willing to take on greater risks in their pursuit of returns, fostering a culture of informal meetings that is yet to take root in Toronto’s formalized investment process.
However, Professor Joshua Gans, the Jeffrey S. Skoll Chair in Technical Innovation and Entrepreneurship, and Chief Economist at the Creative Destruction Lab (CDL), advises against fixating solely on the current VC landscape. While Toronto’s VC ecosystem may not match Silicon Valley’s maturity, Gans emphasizes that VC is just one piece of the puzzle. He underscores Canada’s efforts to enhance its investment climate through startup-friendly policies, mentorship programs, and targeted immigration programs for AI talent.
Between 2021 and 2022, Ontario witnessed a staggering $2.86 billion in VC investment into AI, marking a 206 percent increase from the previous year and signaling substantial growth in AI financing.
Regulatory Hurdles
Regulation has emerged as a contentious issue within the AI industry, with the European Union’s AI Act setting a global precedent as the world’s first comprehensive AI law. Canada, in contrast, lacks an AI regulatory framework.
Professor Avi Goldfarb and Professor Joshua Gans both advocate for striking a delicate balance between regulation and innovation. While excessive regulation can stifle technological advancement, a lack of regulation may erode consumer trust. Both experts assert that fostering a competitive business environment and ensuring robust regulations are vital for the sustainable growth of the AI industry.
Conclusion:
Toronto’s rise as a formidable AI hub represents a significant shift in the tech landscape. While it faces challenges in competing with Silicon Valley’s venture capital dominance and regulatory issues, the city’s continued growth in AI investment and innovation underscores its potential to become a global AI powerhouse. Businesses should take note of Toronto’s expanding AI ecosystem and consider it a viable alternative to established tech hubs.
Source
