Biological Brains Outperform AI in Learning Process

TL;DR:

  • Researchers at the Sainsbury Wellcome Centre published findings on the role of exploratory actions in animal navigation and learning.
  • The study tested the hypothesis that animals’ sensory-driven actions, such as quick dashes toward objects, are crucial in their ability to map and navigate their environment.
  • Experiments showed that even with significant time spent observing and sniffing, mice failed to learn when prevented from running toward obstacles, demonstrating the importance of exploratory actions in learning.
  • The team also ran simulations of various reinforcement learning models commonly used for artificial agents to determine which best-replicated mouse behavior.
  • The mice exhibited both model-free and model-based learning behavior, and the researchers developed an agent capable of arbitrating between the two.
  • The researchers aim to investigate the connection between exploratory actions and subgoal representations in the brain and are currently conducting brain recordings to determine the areas involved.

Main AI News:

In a recent publication in the esteemed journal Neuron, neuroscientists at the Sainsbury Wellcome Centre present their findings on the role of exploratory actions in animal navigation and learning. The study aimed to test the hypothesis that animals’ sensory-guided actions, such as quick dashes toward objects, play a crucial role in their ability to map and navigate their environment.

According to Professor Tiago Branco, Group Leader at SWC and corresponding author of the paper, “There has been much debate in psychology about the impact of specific actions on learning. This study aimed to determine if mere observation of obstacles is sufficient for learning, or if intentional, sensory-driven actions are necessary for building a cognitive map of the world.”

In previous research, the SWC team noted a correlation between successful navigation around obstacles and the number of exploratory runs performed by animals. Building on these findings, Ph.D. student Philip Shamash conducted experiments to examine the impact of inhibiting these exploratory actions.

By expressing the light-activated protein channelrhodopsin in a specific area of the motor cortex, Philip utilized optogenetic tools to prevent mice from initiating exploratory runs toward obstacles. The results were clear – despite the significant time spent observing and sniffing, the mice failed to learn when prevented from running towards obstacles, demonstrating that these instinctive actions are key in helping animals learn their environment.

To delve deeper into the underlying algorithms used by the brain to learn, the researchers at SWC collaborated with Sebastian Lee, a Ph.D. student in Andrew Saxe’s lab, to run simulations of various reinforcement learning models commonly used for artificial agents. The goal was to determine which model best replicated the behavior observed in mice.

The team found that the mice exhibited both model-free and model-based learning behavior, depending on the conditions. To further understand the requirements of a learning algorithm, they developed an agent capable of arbitrating between the two approaches.

According to Professor Branco, “One of the challenges in artificial intelligence is that agents require extensive experience to learn effectively. They must explore the environment thousands of times, whereas a real animal can learn about the same environment in just a few minutes. This efficiency is likely due to the fact that animals’ exploration is not random, but instead focuses on key objects, making the learning process more directed and efficient.”

The researchers’ next objective is to investigate the connection between exploratory actions and the formation of subgoal representations in the brain. They are currently conducting brain recordings to determine the areas involved in representing subgoals and how exploratory actions influence the formation of these representations.

Conlcusion:

The findings of the study on the role of exploratory actions in animal navigation and learning published by the Sainsbury Wellcome Centre provide valuable insights into the learning processes of biological brains and the limitations of artificial intelligence. The research highlights the efficiency of directed exploration in animals’ learning process and the importance of sensory-driven actions in mapping and navigating their environment.

This research has important implications for the market, particularly in the field of artificial intelligence. As the study demonstrates the limitations of current AI algorithms in terms of experience required to learn effectively, there is a significant opportunity for the development of new, more efficient AI algorithms that can learn from a smaller amount of experience. By incorporating the insights from this research, such as the importance of directed exploration, the AI market could see significant advancements in the near future.

Source